jwz - the problem with mash-ups... [entries|archive|friends|userinfo]
jwz

  www.jwz.org
  userinfo
  archive
  rss

Links
[»| DNA (Log) (iCal) WebCollage (LJ) Mixtapes ]

the problem with mash-ups... [Mon, 30-May-2005 4:42 PM]
Previous Entry Add to Memories Tell a Friend Next Entry
[Tags|]
[music |Nelly vs. Lynrd Skynrd -- Sweet Home Country Grammar]

...is that once you get past both "oh, that's unexpected" and "that must have been difficult", what you're left with is a dj with really fucking terrible taste in music.

linkReply

Comments:
[User Picture]From: [info]twiin
Mon, 30-May-2005 4:46 PM (UTC)

(Link)

jwz++
[User Picture]From: [info]iota
Mon, 30-May-2005 4:47 PM (UTC)

(Link)

the real problem is the word 'mash-up'. that phrase makes it sound like someone took a shit on the music, which is most likely true.

it's a god damned remix!
[User Picture]From: [info]jwz
Mon, 30-May-2005 4:53 PM (UTC)

(Link)

Worse, it's a god damned medley.
[User Picture]From: [info]iota
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:04 PM (UTC)

fuck boingboing words

(Link)

i had total web zen when i podcasted that DRM-free mash-up in my blog... i flickr'ed the creative commons licensed pics from the meetup about it, so look for a torrent in my zine soon. disney world.
[User Picture]From: [info]jesus_x
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:51 PM (UTC)

Re: fuck boingboing words

(Link)

This is the "Mission Statement" of weblogs. If you could harness the synergy into a freeform outside-the-box integrated business plan that is enterprise scalable, you could take it to a VC. Two points.
[User Picture]From: [info]iota
Mon, 30-May-2005 7:14 PM (UTC)

Re: fuck boingboing words

(Link)

i sit on the board of losercorp research and development, so you're welcome to paypal me some seed money.
From: [info]greenmustard
Tue, 31-May-2005 8:27 AM (UTC)

Re: fuck boingboing words

(Link)

Banned phrase detected!
[User Picture]From: [info]spendocrat
Tue, 31-May-2005 8:06 PM (UTC)

Re: fuck boingboing words

(Link)

Are you kidding, this baby's off the chart!
From: [info]el_olvidado
Mon, 30-May-2005 4:48 PM (UTC)

(Link)

i want to blow my radio up when live 105 does the six mix...hollaback girl mixed with radio clash is just annoying.
[User Picture]From: [info]jwz
Mon, 30-May-2005 4:51 PM (UTC)

(Link)

I haven't willingly listened to radio in almost eight years. Perhaps you've heard of this invention called a CD player? They can play MP3s now too!
From: [info]el_olvidado
Mon, 30-May-2005 4:56 PM (UTC)

(Link)

i have one...it's just that i have to share a car with two dominant women who torment me on the way home from work.
[User Picture]From: [info]gytterberg
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:05 PM (UTC)

(Link)

When it gets really bad, just think: Some people pay for that.
[User Picture]From: [info]vxo
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:35 PM (UTC)

(Link)

Try something like this. Note that the output's a square wave, so it's going to be very rich in harmonics - the output's power will be distributed across every harmonic from the fundamental frequency up. (Or is it every odd-numbered one?)

Try it, but if it throws off nearby cell phones too, you might want to add a lowpass filter...
[User Picture]From: [info]strspn
Tue, 31-May-2005 2:20 AM (UTC)

(Link)

Awesome! Electronics don't get any more elegant, simple, or illegal than that. 100 MHz crystals are not rare as the linked page suggests -- they are common and cost $0.20 typically. I must try this.

A full-fledged oscilator gives approximate square waves (with odd-only harmonics) but raw quartz with a simple DC bias doesn't.

Overdriven quartz is half a sinusoid and half essentially flat. Anything above about 50 MHz from quartz is driven from overtones alone, which has an even sloppier waveform, which must be how it knocks out the enitre FM band. And cellphones, too? I wonder how. Do you know this from first-hand experience?

And they say crystals don't actually bring peace and harmony.
[User Picture]From: [info]jesus_x
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:52 PM (UTC)

(Link)

And you like it.
[User Picture]From: [info]fo0bar
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:36 PM (UTC)

(Link)

CDs are for music, radios are for NPR.
[User Picture]From: [info]endquote
Mon, 30-May-2005 4:52 PM (UTC)

(Link)

If by annoying you mean "absolutely awesome." Mashups require a real sense of humor to appreciate, which [info]jwz isn't really known for. They tend to be a lot more about "fun to listen to" than about being "quality music", and some are certainly better than others.

I recommend checking out mixes by Shir Khan, who's a lot better than Party Ben (which is who does Sixx Mixx, though I love him too).
[User Picture]From: [info]gargargar
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:43 PM (UTC)

Novelty records

(Link)

No, wait, don't tell me. Your record collection is largely Weird Al Yankovic, Peter Shikele, and Doctor Demento productions.

Novelty records vs. Good Music aside, jwz's objection to the fad seems to be that the "fun to listen to" aspects of these tracks last for only about the first few bars. After the first part, your reaction tends to be "okay, okay, I GET IT ALREADY!"
[User Picture]From: [info]otterley
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:48 PM (UTC)

Re: Novelty records

(Link)

My objection to the fad is that people seem to be oblivious to the fact that it was interesting for approximately the same amount of time when the technique was invented twenty years ago.
[User Picture]From: [info]baconmonkey
Mon, 30-May-2005 7:24 PM (UTC)

Re: Novelty records

(Link)

Turntable mixing is more than 30 years old.

Sonic Foundry (now owned by Sony) put out the first version of "Acid" in 1997.

Mashups are almost exclusively created via digital editing software like Acid, then a button-jockey presses play and OMG, 2 Songs (pre-recorded) At Once!!!!

There are the moments of Brilliance out there, but mostly it's overplayed-pop-swill-of-the-moment played with overplayed-pop-swill-from-10-to-20-years-ago. For a moment of brilliance, I point to Ausoween, which predates the term "mashup" by many years. But I may be biassed, because I had pretty much the same idea concerning those two songs years ago, but lacked access to good high-end digital editing software like Pro Tools.
[User Picture]From: [info]jwz
Mon, 30-May-2005 9:57 PM (UTC)

Kurt must PAY.

(Link)

See, that song would be the canonical example of "clever once". It's not even that good a mix; after the first switch, most of it is just a muddy mess.

AND, it has the inexcusable fucking side effect that any time someone writes "Ich Bin Ein Auslander" on the request list, the DJ translates that to "Ausoween" instead. Because that's. You know. Funnier. Or gother. Or something.

When's the last time you've heard the original in a club? It's like it doesn't even exist any more.
[User Picture]From: [info]muftak
Tue, 31-May-2005 11:56 PM (UTC)

Re: Kurt must PAY.

(Link)

that Ausoween remix is, um, interesting...
have never heard it played before, they always play the orininal here in england
[User Picture]From: [info]endquote
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:00 PM (UTC)

Re: Novelty records

(Link)

You're not going to find much in the way of "club music" (or western music for that matter) that is so complex that you can't figure it out in the course of a few bars or a few songs. There are a million four-piece bands that play their music in more-or-less the same way, and are totally predictable, but that doesn't mean they're not good music. Speaking specifically of mashups, the example used here is really not the best -- there are other tracks that mix bits of four or five others as opposed to just two, which are a lot more interesting than Nelly vs. Lynrd Skynrd.
[User Picture]From: [info]gargargar
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:33 PM (UTC)

Re: Novelty records

(Link)

I'll just mark you down for "yes" on the Doctor Demento collection then, shall I?
[User Picture]From: [info]endquote
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:51 PM (UTC)

Re: Novelty records

(Link)

Not so much. I'll mark you down for "yes" on the "prefers insults to arguments" column.
[User Picture]From: [info]flipping_hades
Mon, 30-May-2005 9:45 PM (UTC)

Re: Novelty records

(Link)

That's pretty much what you'll find 'round here. Get used to it, it's only livejournal.
[User Picture]From: [info]flipping_hades
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:56 PM (UTC)

(Link)

"quality music" is generally a prerequisite for achieving "fun to listen to" without the aid of mind-altering substances. Actually, even with them.
[User Picture]From: [info]endquote
Mon, 30-May-2005 6:04 PM (UTC)

(Link)

True, but only when you're taking yourself or the music way too seriously.

Relax, it's only music.
[User Picture]From: [info]cow
Mon, 30-May-2005 7:30 PM (UTC)

(Link)

I imagine, on top of what's noted above, you also find anime "music videos" awesome and original, too.
[User Picture]From: [info]specialagentm
Tue, 31-May-2005 8:34 AM (UTC)

(Link)

Hey! Some of those are fun! :-)

(But yes, Sturgeon's Law, blah blah blah)
[User Picture]From: [info]strspn
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:04 PM (UTC)

(Link)

Smash-Up Derby does it the right way.... as you know from first-hand experience.
[User Picture]From: [info]jwz
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:08 PM (UTC)

(Link)

Smash Up Derby are fun, but Storm and the Balls are ten thousand times better.
[User Picture]From: [info]fo0bar
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:37 PM (UTC)

(Link)

Lazyweb, what is a mash-up?
[User Picture]From: [info]fo0bar
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:39 PM (UTC)

(Link)

Ah, like that Real Slim Shady/Oops I Did It Again thing from the 90s.
[User Picture]From: [info]iota
Mon, 30-May-2005 7:15 PM (UTC)

(Link)

yes but this is THE YEAR TWO THOULSAND, where things aren't called by regular names!
[User Picture]From: [info]fo0bar
Mon, 30-May-2005 7:26 PM (UTC)

(Link)

THE YEAR TWO THOULSAND?!? I've been thrown back in time! I must warn people about 9-Eleven and the war! And maipulate the stock market! And buy some New Coke! And go to a bar!
[User Picture]From: [info]korgmeister
Tue, 31-May-2005 8:37 AM (UTC)

(Link)

Reads, remembers he liked that Slim Shady remix.

Downloads a bunch of others from links in the Wikipedia article.

Realises that most of them are really shite.

Regains a new thankfulness for the delete key.
[User Picture]From: [info]baconmonkey
Mon, 30-May-2005 5:43 PM (UTC)

(Link)

perhaps a mash-up of "Mashed Potato Time" by Dee Dee Sharpe and "Get up (sexmachine)" by James Brown would create a vortex of Irony so great that it would cause the entire Mash-up world to implode in on itself?
[User Picture]From: [info]chronovore
Mon, 30-May-2005 10:11 PM (UTC)

(Link)

Apparently it exists somewhere already, as this world is already so fuX0red as to defy logical interpretation.
[User Picture]From: [info]relaxing
Tue, 31-May-2005 6:38 AM (UTC)

(Link)

[User Picture]From: [info]fantasygoat
Tue, 31-May-2005 8:55 AM (UTC)

(Link)

Mash-ups are the aural equivalent of forwarded email jokes.
[User Picture]From: [info]mysterc
Tue, 31-May-2005 9:21 AM (UTC)

(Link)

"Mash ups" are what the "DJ's" I grew up listening to did in the early 80's. They called it "mixing"
[User Picture]From: [info]5beroptic
Tue, 31-May-2005 11:57 AM (UTC)

(Link)

It was stated earlier but I simply can't take a mash-up very seriously at_all to be honest. People seem to think two bad songs make one good one but to each there own. The only time a mash-up seems proper is on a bad radio show or at club where people have consumed enough booze to knock an elephant over.
[User Picture]From: [info]sherbooke
Tue, 31-May-2005 4:06 PM (UTC)

mash-ups

(Link)

so uncool, uh?

as an aesthetic relation to William Burroughs, hell, mash-ups do better than most things floating round the aether these day

Look at the overall picture rather than the intermediate one which you seemed to be tuned to. Fragments joined to make a greater whole - that was point, no? You frame quotidien so that it becomes so.

Is your taste that much better? I guess not.




[User Picture]From: [info]benchilada
Wed, 1-Jun-2005 10:05 AM (UTC)

(Link)

I call clever "mash-ups" by the more dignified "versus" tag.
Ones like the ricockulously fun "Closer to Wannabe" -- NIN v. Spice Girls and the seamlessly made "Intergalactic Guerilla Radio" -- Beastie Boys v. Rage Against the Machine, both of which sit happily on the music drive of my 'puter.

I call shitty ones "somebody with PCDJ and too much time on their hands."
[User Picture]From: [info]philipkd
Fri, 3-Jun-2005 9:05 PM (UTC)

Danger Mouse

(Link)

Nobody liked DJ Danger Mouse's mash-up?
[User Picture]From: [info]kokopoko
Fri, 22-Dec-2006 6:20 PM (UTC)

(Link)

I kinda like mashups. If they're not that bad. And I love DangerMouse.