| Comments: |
Heck, if you're willing to posit that trasubstantiation actually takes place, it's not that far a leap to say that everyone ingests the same eternally renewing Body and Blood of Christ, over and over again.
Sure. Jesus was dead and in the ground before anyone took communion. His flesh and blood were gone. So if God can reconstitute Jesus's body from that, there's no reason he can't reclaim them once again from the bodies and/or bodily wastes of Catholics who eat him.
Unless you consider the Last Supper to have been the first communion, in which case it's even more confusing. But I imagine the Catholic church doesn't, because that would almost require that the transformation be symbolic.
According to the literature in the bathroom at my in-laws....the Catholic Church belives this to be true today...not just as recently as 1965.
Maybe I misunderstand what you're saying.
this is true the catholic church still believes this
Actually, it's really more of a loaves and fishes thing.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/5887295/515656) | From: jwz Mon, 25-Apr-2005 4:51 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
They don't actually think he's a fish, that's just an acronym. I don't believe this to be a "Shadow Over Innsmouth" type of outbreak.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/29332494/6917618) | From: mato Mon, 25-Apr-2005 4:50 PM (UTC)
Frink? | (Link)
|
Did you just discover Frink?
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/5887295/515656) | From: jwz Mon, 25-Apr-2005 4:53 PM (UTC)
Re: Frink? | (Link)
|
Never heard of it. I do all my math in Emacs Lisp, with occasional help from /usr/bin/units.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/5887295/515656) | From: jwz Mon, 25-Apr-2005 4:56 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
That's awesome.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/23163723/466222) | From: g_na Mon, 25-Apr-2005 4:54 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
A and B don't add up. I'm assuming A takes into account that many people who are baptised catholic eventually eschew the religion once they are old enough to think for themselves.
Communion wafers are much smaller than Ritz crackers. I'm guessing 1/4-1/8 the size of one Ritz, and with less fat.
Catholics nowadays almost never drink the "blood". The priest will "transubstantiate" some wine and take a sip, but it's almost never given to the general public. Maybe they're running out of blood?
The average person sheds 18kg/40 lbs of skin in a lifetime (source: Human Anatomy, Marieb & Mallatt, PeArson Education 2003).
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/28828275/466222) | From: g_na Mon, 25-Apr-2005 5:01 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
Oh, also for G - that would be everytime they go to church, and catholics are supposed to go once per week.
I'm way too lazy to look it up, but I'm pretty sure communion wafers are a *lot* thinner than a ritz cracker.
So it's quite possible Jesus is only 250x larger than a blue whale.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/5887295/515656) | From: jwz Mon, 25-Apr-2005 4:58 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
The 2500 figure is "whale vs. person", not "jesus vs. whale."
In 2001, Clarke claimed that the ratio of dead to living was 30:1, but I don't know whether this was a projection made when 2001 was written, or based on the time that it was written.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/5887295/515656) | From: jwz Mon, 25-Apr-2005 5:05 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
He was counting all the way back to homo erectus or something, so that doesn't really help.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/54541970/2) | From: brad Mon, 25-Apr-2005 5:01 PM (UTC)
My Jesus | (Link)
|
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/996772/447266) | From: ydna Mon, 25-Apr-2005 5:05 PM (UTC)
Re: My Jesus | (Link)
|
Ha! I just got my copy today (with a new PS2).
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/7549650/382082) | From: zenmonkeykstop Mon, 25-Apr-2005 5:08 PM (UTC)
Once I caught a Jesus |------------this------------| big... | (Link)
|
I remember hearing that at one stage, there were enough relics of the cross floating around Europe to make a dozen of them. Noow we know why.
Humans allegedly shed about 40 pounds of skin in their lifetime. I can't find out any facts on how much of that ends up in other peoples' food, though.
What always got me is this: if you can use anything as the host for communion, and the host "becomes" the flesh of Christ, why not use a cadaver? Wouldn't that essentially bring Jesus back to life into someone's body?
Actually, what you'd have is a lifeless Jesus-clone. :-) Without the soul/spirit/spark of life/whatever you choose to call it, it's still just a dead body. And theoretically he's got better things to do Upstairs than come down to tell us what naughty boys and girls we've been.
Unless you feel that the formula of transsubstantiation is strong enough that Jesus would be drawn into the body whether he wants to or not. Then you might get a ressurected Jesus, or maybe even a Zombie Jesus. That would be fun.
We shed 1.5 million skin cells every hour with a new skin surface every 28 to 30 days or so.
Wow, you truly are a gentleman of leisure.
Actually, catholics can (and often do) take the Eucharist at every mass, which would mean every week (or even everyday, for hardcore believers). My childhood memory going to the church was that roughly half of the congregation every week stood up to take communion. OTOH, as people have pointed out, nobody except the priest drank the wine. And of course, I don't know to what extent this is extrapolable to the last 2000 years.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/28828275/466222) | From: g_na Mon, 25-Apr-2005 5:18 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
I don't know to what extent this is extrapolable to the last 2000 years.
Good point. I wonder how long catholicism has been around? One thousand years? 750?
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/78674788/922107) | From: leolo Mon, 25-Apr-2005 6:02 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
According to Roman Catholic dogma, transubstantiation is the change of the substance of the Eucharistic elements — bread and wine — into the body and blood of Jesus, although they retain the physical accidents — i.e. appearance, taste, texture, etc.— of bread and wine.
From Wikipedia
I'd also guess more clues could be had by wading through ECCLESIA DE EUCHARISTIA but I don't have any patience for papal encyclical letters.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/5887295/515656) | From: jwz Mon, 25-Apr-2005 6:05 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
What's your point?
That Wikipedia article goes on to say "bread and wine are really absent, and this presence and absence is real and not merely something in the mind of the believer."
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/76104386/6918574) | From: kzinti Mon, 25-Apr-2005 6:02 PM (UTC)
What a concept... | (Link)
|
For people who take communion in my church (Methodist), the ritual is merely symbolic cannibalism. For Catholics, though, it's actual cannibalism. Cool. Thou art God.
"Stranger in a Strange Land" reference, I assume? Hmm ... makes me wonder what other subtle jabs Heinlein may have tossed in that I overlooked (assuming this was intentional.)
catholicism is so funny, they _really_ sit down and think some things out, and other things it seems like they ran with a whim on drugs.. but of course I guess it was the 60's.
I'm not religious, but if I was going to be I would go (back) to catholicism, if they would only say 'we sat down and thought about it and it makes best sense to us if...' instead of 'the holy ghost came to us and said'.
This math is assuming each person were to receive only One communion in their lifetime?!
Don't most Catholics take up the cup Every week?
therefore we'd have to take 23,000,000,000 (the typical lifespan in years - 8) so for an easy number let's take 78 as the "typical" liespan and then subtract 8 *calculating* = 70...X56 weeks/year...
so we have 23,000,000,000 (70*56) = 90,160,000,000,000 so let's toss that into the equation and see where it brings us!
23,000,000,000 people × 12 % × 3920 communion × 2000 years = unGodly number here
(this moment of sheer stupidity has been tossed your way out of complete desperation to avoid thinking about homework-sorry to take it out on you)
Is it blasphemy to consume an ungodly amount of a supposed god?
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/3445637/345723) | From: otterley Mon, 25-Apr-2005 6:54 PM (UTC)
The Fluoride Effect | (Link)
|
What did you have for breakfast today? Because I want some.
I once heard that 75% of household dust is dead human skin cells. Now you just need numbers for how fast it accumulates.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/48822320/419523) | From: obra Mon, 25-Apr-2005 8:24 PM (UTC)
| (Link)
|
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/5887295/515656) | From: jwz Mon, 25-Apr-2005 8:31 PM (UTC)
Towing Jehovah | (Link)
|
That's a fantastic book. The sequels aren't as good, though.
And to think I always thought regeneration in omnipotent beings was assumed. Stupid me.
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/83233170/2888683) | From: mysterc Mon, 25-Apr-2005 9:52 PM (UTC)
From the one person you know who doesn't want to go to hell... | (Link)
|
Your formula does not include the all powerful nature of God.
The formula should read: 23,000,000,000 people × 12 % × 1 communion × 2000 years = 5,520,000,000,000 servings
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- × 0.25 fl. oz. = 10,781,250,000 gallons of blood
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- × 20 grams = 243,390,340,000 pounds of flesh = 121,695,170 tons of flesh x (n=Alpha+Omega)= Whatever the bible says it does...
This is the answer that the nuns always gave me (a recovering catholic) whenever I tried to introduce logic into the teachings of the Catholic Church.
God bless
From: dcdan Tue, 26-Apr-2005 7:31 AM (UTC)
Re: From the one person you know who doesn't want to go to hell... | (Link)
|
The euphemism for "Whatever the bible says it does..." is now officaially known as "Faith Based Initiatives"
this begs the question: does transubstatiated flesh run the full digestive course?
if yes, there is a huge ammount of literally holy shit out there. that also puts a new spin on the Pisschrist work.
Now my question is, does Jesus have an excess of either flesh or blood? What's the normal ratio of blood:body in an adult male? If he's got extra blood, he may be regularly donating it - you could have a bit of Jesus in you.
From: debi_v Thu, 28-Apr-2005 8:37 PM (UTC)
I might have a bit of Jesus in me... | (Link)
|
You'll probably just find this annoying, but of all the comments I was reading about the whole Catholic-Christ-Communion-transformation thing, yours grabbed my attention most and actually caused me to register on this site so I could respond.[Thank you very much.] I was Catholic once, but never made it to the the Communion years. I remember being quite annoyed at the time because my parents converted right before I was to wear the white dress and veil when I was 7-years-old (yet thrilled that I no longer had to attend Catholic School).
Anyway...
I don't believe in religion, I believe in a relationship with God who created me, and His Son who was sent to redeem me through his death and resurrection. You could call me "born-again", but then I would fall into that category that so many in this country despise.
I just wanted to comment on your choice of words: "a bit of Jesus in me". It's kinda like if if someone had the cure for cancer and met someone with cancer. It wouldn't be fair to keep such information to oneself. I've got Jesus in me (and I'm not a freak), and because of that, I've got the gift of eternal life. It wouldn't be fair not to share it with you.
There. I've said my piece. Now I can go to bed. Man, I'm tired.
...Oh, and I receive communion now when I go to church. It's just crackers and juice, for pete's sake... :-) Symbolism... Hello?
![[User Picture]](http://l-userpic.livejournal.com/2035049/592038) | From: arucard Tue, 26-Apr-2005 7:31 AM (UTC)
Gluten free wafers | (Link)
|
Hi I saw this on BoingBoing, and thought you might be interested to know about another problem with the whole transubstantiation thing....
If, when you eat the wafer, it transforms into the flesh of Christ, then it's not the actual wafer you're eating, is it? it wouldn't matter what was in the wafer
So why the heck do they make gluten free communion wafers for people with allergies? Could it be that they don't have *that* much faith that it really will turn into the flesh of Christ? | |